« On Violence’s 300th P… | Home | War is War is Heinlei… »

Why The ROCK Went Down the Valley

The Battle of Wanat has slowly come to epitomize America’s decade-and-more-long adventure in Afghanistan. The final report, released last month, garnered significant media coverage. Even though the Battle of Kamdesh occurred a year later with roughly the same results, it still doesn’t seem to get the same respect.  

I was in 2nd Battalion of the 503rd Infantry Regiment, The ROCK, the unit responsible for Wanat. Thus far, I have avoided voicing my opinion. Not that my opinion doesn’t matter--I just know too many people in too many places that I could offend with my blogging.

I do believe, though, I can provide at least one perspective that I haven’t seen in any of the coverage: a visceral explanation of why our battalion moved to Wanat.

Before Wanat, Chosen Company controlled two Combat Out Posts in the Waygal valley: COP Ranch House and COP Bella. In August of the 2007, Ranch House was nearly overrun in a Wanat-style attack. (Actually, Wanat was a Ranch House-style attack.) Through amazing fortune, no one was killed, though several soldiers were wounded.

After the attack, our battalion pulled back to COP Bella. But COP Bella, which supported Ranch House, wasn’t much better. It had high ground on every side, and was in probably more danger than Ranch House or Wanat. I never set foot on Bella, but I was in a helicopter that landed there to drop off some PAX on my way back to Camp Joyce.



Look at the rocks that surrounded Bella. Look at the size of the hills. Yeah COP Kahler/Wanat had high ground around it, but nothing like Bella. That is why the decision to go to Wanat started. We can second guess the decisions related to building the base and supporting the operation until we are blue in the face,  but the point remains: in the Waygal valley, there were no good options and no easy answers, which in war there rarely are.

six comments

I’m glad you took this pic. and you’re right, I haven’t read this analysis any where else.


This is like a trailer. It’s good in that it’s new and insightful, but it leaves me wanting more.


Why build a base in a valley? Was whomever made that choice retarded?


Having a base in a valley reminded my of this quote from Inglourious Basterds:

“Well, you don’t got to be Stonewall Jackson to know you don’t want to fight in a basement.”


I disagree with the comment thqt this analysis is new and unreported. The Army CSI’s study does emphasize this point greatly. A copy of that study is avaialble free online and is linked at the Wikepedia page on Wanat. The decision to move to Wanat was actually made to lessen risk in the Waygal Valley, not as osme foolhardly end of tour mission.


I think the commenter didn’t mean so much that this is new information—we hardly ever think that our views are new and exciting. I think he meant this is under reported more than new and exciting.

Too few people have read the CSI report, which is still far from the last word on this battle.